The Confidence Paradox and Tall Poppy Syndrome


Hi Reader

Almost every athlete I’ve worked with has shared a common goal: to grow their confidence.

Yet, many follow that with a hesitation: “But I don’t want to come across as arrogant.”

It’s not uncommon for athletes working on their mindset and confidence to be labeled as “arrogant.”

But let’s be clear—what’s often perceived as arrogance is simply an athlete striving to be their best, getting in the zone, and rallying their self-belief.

For athletes, confidence can feel like walking a tightrope.

You’re ready to rise to the occasion, but the fear of standing out—or worse, being judged or cut down—can hold you back.

This delicate balance is what I call the confidence paradox, and it often intersects with the challenges of tall poppy syndrome.

The Confidence Paradox

Confidence is a skill, not a sudden gift.

It grows through action, yet stepping into action often demands a level of confidence you might not feel you have—an almost circular dilemma.

Many athletes grapple with questions like:

  • "How can I perform with confidence when success feels uncertain?"
  • "How can I believe in myself when I’ve yet to prove I can handle the pressure?"

Confidence doesn’t strike like lightning.

It’s built step by step—by taking action, overcoming challenges, and proving to yourself that you are capable.

Every small victory builds the foundation for greater self-belief.

Tall Poppy Syndrome

As your confidence grows and you begin to excel, you may encounter societal or cultural pressures telling you to "stay in your lane" or warning you not to "get too big for your boots."

This is tall poppy syndrome—a mindset that makes standing out feel risky, as if success invites criticism or envy.

But consider this: Greatness doesn’t shrink.

When you stand tall and achieve, you pave the way for others to aspire and grow.

Yes, growth comes with challenges, but it also creates waves of inspiration that uplift those around you.

A Final Thought

Standing tall isn’t about overshadowing others; it’s about lighting the way.

By embracing your confidence, you’re not just overcoming your own barriers—you’re inspiring others to aim higher too.

As the holiday season approaches and the year comes to a close, it's natural to reflect on your journey—celebrating wins, learning from challenges, and setting intentions for the future.

As you do, remember to stay grounded in your growth and unapologetic in your ambition.

Looking ahead to 2025, I’m opening up a few coaching spaces to help athletes like you start the new year with renewed confidence and focus.

If you’re ready to kick off 2025 with a powerful mindset, drop me a message—I’d love to chat about how we can work together to achieve your goals.

Stay positive, stay focused, and keep moving forward.

Lisa

PS: Book a ​30 minute FREE mindset strategy call whenever you are ready

PPS: Join the Winner's Circle here

111 Medhurst Road, Auckland, Auckland 2675

You're getting this because you showed an interest in Winning Ways or purchased a product or service from us. If you no longer find these emails helpful or interesting, you can Unsubscribe with no hard feelings or Update Your Preferences.

Winning Ways Weekly

Learn something new every Friday! Join 150+ athletes and sports people just like you who are growing their performance with mindset strategies and topics that work to help them win in their sport and their lives.

Read more from Winning Ways Weekly
A roller coaster in an amusement park

Hi Reader I always felt nerves before competing — sometimes even during. But ironically, that wasn’t the hardest part for me. Once I was in the competition, I had control. I could double down on my process, focus on executing my routine, and adjust as needed to get the results I wanted. I could take care of my nutrition, stay hydrated, and find learning experiences in everything I did. The real challenge? The days and weeks leading up to competition. That stretch of time felt like a...

a man holding a pole in a gym

Hi Reader As both an athlete and a coach, I’ve had the privilege of watching the world’s best perform — under pressure, in training, and beyond competition. I’ve worked alongside them, studied their habits, and now, as a coach, I see firsthand what truly sets them apart. Every day, I get to work with athletes who strive for greatness. And I’ve seen the difference between those who rise to the top and those who plateau. So, what separates elite athletes from everyone else? It’s not just...

A woman with dreadlocks standing in front of a basketball hoop

Hi Reader As a child, I loved watching the Olympics. I would wake up early, captivated by sports I had never even seen before. I marveled at the grace, strength, and precision of these athletes. They seemed almost untouchable—living in a world I believed I could never reach. That’s why, when I eventually started competing at an elite level, I struggled with imposter syndrome. I distinctly remember the first time I received my accreditation for a major competition. It had my photo, my name,...